Start Customizing My Cake

If you are looking for a completely customizable cake for that special occassion, it starts here!

Are You Ready to Design Your Cake?

Choose your flavour, filling, size, etc. from the dropdown menus below and provide any details in the box provided. We will call you once your order has been received. If you need some inspiration, check out our gallery. Please give us 48 hours prior to pick-up. Special decorations will require advance notice. If additional information is required, please give us a call at (519) 940-5858.

To see additional cake creations from our team, please visit our social media accounts. Links are provided below.

Customize My Cake

Customize your very own cake from the flavour and fillings to your finishes and size. The way you like it is the way we will make it.

Please note: For the Vegan flavour, we only can provide 6″, 8″ and 10″ sizes.

Important: If you are uploading an image along with your inquiry, please use a desktop computer.

      Cupcakes for Any Occasion You Can Think Of

      Whether its for your son or daughters birthday, for that special anniversary, or simply just a night to self indulge, our cupcakes will have them and yourself talking for months after.

      What Our Customers Are Saying!

      chance kershen
      March 13, 2022
      N. Chaudhry
      March 4, 2022

      The cupcakes are amazing. I’ll be ordering again at the first chance I get.

      Paul Alves
      February 28, 2022

      Great place in our community. Yummy cupcakes and homemade food and sweets.

      Elaine Wakeman
      January 30, 2022

      Ordered a hot wheels cake for my son's second birthday and everything was perfect😊 Thank you and we will be seeing you again

      Ian Thomas
      December 22, 2021

      Great place, great food , great people …

      Nicole Sartor
      November 18, 2021

      Beautiful cakes and nut free.

      Cathy H
      November 6, 2021

      Baby shower cake, it was gorgeous and delicious ! Centre piece for the shower . Everyone was impressed . Sent a picture of what I had in mind turned out way better than expected. Thank you

      cristina murphy
      October 29, 2021

      Very good vanilla cake! Can't wait to try other flavour!

      Tony Licata
      October 29, 2021

      Great service, great cakes.

      Selena vieira
      September 14, 2021

      They made my baby shower cake. It was an amazing hit. Everyone asked where I got the cake from. The design was perfect and the flavour was spot on. Such a moist cake! Not to mention the price is unbeatable.

      Donna Seylelr
      September 7, 2021

      Quest for Cakes did an awesome catering job for our Birthday event on Sept 5th. The food was so good, and people were commenting on how good it all was. The cakes were amazing and so good! I would use Quest for Cakes again and again. Their help with all of it made planning so easy. Thank you for your wonderful work! Donna S.

      Mark Shibish
      September 6, 2021

      Over the years I continue to order all our family birthday and special events cakes here. Recently celebrating my mother's 80th birthday and purchased additional desserts. Everything in the photo. Everything was tasty, and wonderful. Our guests were loving everything especially the cupcakes and pies. The custom cake was light not too sweet. Perfect. A Peanut/ Nut Free facility making it easy when planning for large group, family events for those with allergies. Thank you for consistently providing great service and quality baked goods.

      matty0698
      June 27, 2021
      Christina Jimenez
      June 13, 2021

      This bakery not only made my son's baptism cake exactly how I asked but they were able to provide individually packaged cupcakes for my family members to take to the rest of our family that were unable to attend due to covid restrictions. This was so helpful and I didn't worry about them having a mess of cupcakes that I would have had to put in tupperware for them to take. The cake and cupcakes were affordable and tasted good, not dry or overly sweet. The only thing I found difficult was not being able to fully correspond through email - I found everytime I had time to call to confirm the order details it was past 3pm, the times (hours of operation) to call were a bit hard for me personally but other than that, great place.

      Laura B
      June 11, 2021
      Ami Patel
      May 8, 2021
      Justin Mohammed
      April 10, 2021
      Jill Dixon
      August 1, 2020
      David Straughan
      May 30, 2020

      Very good mains and desserts.

      Karen Sodoma
      May 24, 2020

      I ordered two custom cakes for my twin daughters 18th birthday. Pam called me and patiently explained all my options and made great suggestions. Excellent customer service!! The cakes were so beautiful and tasted amazing! I will continue to order cakes and I highly recommend Quest for Cakes!

      linda vw
      May 14, 2020

      I’ve order pulled pork from Pam for a large gathering the last couple of summers and each time the pork was amazing. Today I called for a very small specialty order and Pam went out of her way to help. Incredible service as well as delicious food - great combination.

      Stefanie B
      March 14, 2020

      We got a small vegan chocolate cake for my mother in law's birthday and I was presently surprised. It tasted great, and the price was great too. Vegan cakes are pretty hard to come by. I definitely recommend this place to anybody who's looking for one. They also have a lot of other baked goods that aren't vegan that my husband and I are dying to try.

      Karen Liz
      March 13, 2020

      Love all of the treats they make. Friendly service too!

      Galadia Murphy
      February 10, 2020

      Best Turtles Cake ever!

      Erin Walmsley
      January 21, 2020
      Ezequiel Calvo Paz
      January 1, 2020
      kathleen roy
      December 24, 2019
      Jamie K
      December 8, 2019

      Very professional and well done cakes

      Mad Momma
      December 6, 2019
      S. Kashyap
      November 28, 2019
      kulvir singh
      November 21, 2019

      Good place in town for cakes...

      Elizabeth Tozer
      November 9, 2019

      I ordered cupcakes for my daughter's 4th Birthday for all of the kids in her class and teachers. Her & all of the kids loved the cupcakes plus the teachers.

      Carol Marchand
      November 8, 2019
      Jeanne Dawson
      November 5, 2019

      They helped me make a 65th custom cake for my mother in law and make our wedding cake for a small party. Always delicious. Plus they have the best cannoli's.

      jen hunt
      October 18, 2019
      Tim A
      October 18, 2019
      WavyBacon
      September 25, 2019
      Krista Williams
      August 24, 2019

      Quest for Cakes is amazing. I ordered my daughter's first birthday cake and to say they did an amazing job is an understatement. My husband even liked it which says a lot. Will definitely be going there for all of my cakes.

      Melissa Pastore
      August 16, 2019
      Sara Bona
      July 15, 2019
      Mandeep D
      July 9, 2019

      I've ordered kids birthday cakes 2 yrs in a row and the women that work there are just magical. They are able to take your ideas and have an image on the cake. Overall the cake is so fluffy and tasty my kids and I didnt have one complaint. Gluten free, egg free, nut free it's just the right place to get your cakes, cupcakes and cookies from.

      Lindsay Roberts
      July 8, 2019

      The cake is pretty tasty but I do find their prices high. I also sometimes feel when I walk in that I'm a nuisance for being there. I still go in for a big chocolate chip cookie for my kids or the occasional cupcake though 🙂

      Sabah Ivan
      June 26, 2019

      Great job done! The cake was so good for my daughter's 10th birthday. It was moist and everyone loved it. We just moved to orangeville and am so glad i found this cake shop. I will be going there more often now for all my baking needs. Thank you!

      Meg Twigg
      June 12, 2019
      TGunn1000 “TGunn1000”
      June 9, 2019

      Dangerously bad for my health. Everything is good and I still haven't tried everything.

      m B
      May 27, 2019

      Love the cookies

      Linda Sawden
      May 18, 2019
      Fawn Lengyel
      May 17, 2019
      Nick m
      April 15, 2019
      Kyle Johnson
      April 14, 2019

      The best cup cakes!

      If you’d like to leave a review on your most recent experience, you can do so by clicking the link below. We would sincerely appreciate it and be forever grateful.

      Subscribe To Our New Newsletter

      Join our mailing list to receive the latest product news and updates from the bakery.

      Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.

      chance kershen
      chance kershen

      Just left us a 4 star review

      on
      google
      google
      chance kershen
      March 13, 2022
      google
      N. Chaudhry
      March 4, 2022

      The cupcakes are amazing. I’ll be ordering again at the first chance I get.

      google
      Paul Alves
      February 28, 2022

      Great place in our community. Yummy cupcakes and homemade food and sweets.

      google
      Elaine Wakeman
      January 30, 2022

      Ordered a hot wheels cake for my son's second birthday and everything was perfect😊 Thank you and we will be seeing you again

      google
      Ian Thomas
      December 22, 2021

      Great place, great food , great people …

      google
      Nicole Sartor
      November 18, 2021

      Beautiful cakes and nut free.

      google
      Cathy H
      November 6, 2021

      Baby shower cake, it was gorgeous and delicious ! Centre piece for the shower . Everyone was impressed . Sent a picture of what I had in mind turned out way better than expected. Thank you

      google
      cristina murphy
      October 29, 2021

      Very good vanilla cake! Can't wait to try other flavour!

      google
      Tony Licata
      October 29, 2021

      Great service, great cakes.

      google
      Selena vieira
      September 14, 2021

      They made my baby shower cake. It was an amazing hit. Everyone asked where I got the cake from. The design was perfect and the flavour was spot on. Such a moist cake! Not to mention the price is unbeatable.

      google
      Donna Seylelr
      September 7, 2021

      Quest for Cakes did an awesome catering job for our Birthday event on Sept 5th. The food was so good, and people were commenting on how good it all was. The cakes were amazing and so good! I would use Quest for Cakes again and again. Their help with all of it made planning so easy. Thank you for your wonderful work! Donna S.

      google
      Mark Shibish
      September 6, 2021

      Over the years I continue to order all our family birthday and special events cakes here. Recently celebrating my mother's 80th birthday and purchased additional desserts. Everything in the photo. Everything was tasty, and wonderful. Our guests were loving everything especially the cupcakes and pies. The custom cake was light not too sweet. Perfect. A Peanut/ Nut Free facility making it easy when planning for large group, family events for those with allergies. Thank you for consistently providing great service and quality baked goods.

      google
      matty0698
      June 27, 2021

      This bakery not only made my son's baptism cake exactly how I asked but they were able to provide individually packaged cupcakes for my family members to take to the rest of our family that were unable to attend due to covid restrictions. This was so helpful and I didn't worry about them having a mess of cupcakes that I would have had to put in tupperware for them to take. The cake and cupcakes were affordable and tasted good, not dry or overly sweet. The only thing I found difficult was not being able to fully correspond through email - I found everytime I had time to call to confirm the order details it was past 3pm, the times (hours of operation) to call were a bit hard for me personally but other than that, great place.

      google
      Laura B
      June 11, 2021
      google
      Ami Patel
      May 8, 2021
      google
      Justin Mohammed
      April 10, 2021
      google
      Jill Dixon
      August 1, 2020
      google
      David Straughan
      May 30, 2020

      Very good mains and desserts.

      google
      Karen Sodoma
      May 24, 2020

      I ordered two custom cakes for my twin daughters 18th birthday. Pam called me and patiently explained all my options and made great suggestions. Excellent customer service!! The cakes were so beautiful and tasted amazing! I will continue to order cakes and I highly recommend Quest for Cakes!

      google
      linda vw
      May 14, 2020

      I’ve order pulled pork from Pam for a large gathering the last couple of summers and each time the pork was amazing. Today I called for a very small specialty order and Pam went out of her way to help. Incredible service as well as delicious food - great combination.

      google
      Stefanie B
      March 14, 2020

      We got a small vegan chocolate cake for my mother in law's birthday and I was presently surprised. It tasted great, and the price was great too. Vegan cakes are pretty hard to come by. I definitely recommend this place to anybody who's looking for one. They also have a lot of other baked goods that aren't vegan that my husband and I are dying to try.

      google
      Karen Liz
      March 13, 2020

      Love all of the treats they make. Friendly service too!

      google
      Galadia Murphy
      February 10, 2020

      Best Turtles Cake ever!

      google
      Erin Walmsley
      January 21, 2020
      google
      Ezequiel Calvo Paz
      January 1, 2020
      google
      kathleen roy
      December 24, 2019
      google
      Jamie K
      December 8, 2019

      Very professional and well done cakes

      google
      Mad Momma
      December 6, 2019
      google
      S. Kashyap
      November 28, 2019
      google
      kulvir singh
      November 21, 2019

      Good place in town for cakes...

      google
      Elizabeth Tozer
      November 9, 2019

      I ordered cupcakes for my daughter's 4th Birthday for all of the kids in her class and teachers. Her & all of the kids loved the cupcakes plus the teachers.

      google
      Carol Marchand
      November 8, 2019
      google
      Jeanne Dawson
      November 5, 2019

      They helped me make a 65th custom cake for my mother in law and make our wedding cake for a small party. Always delicious. Plus they have the best cannoli's.

      google
      jen hunt
      October 18, 2019
      google
      Tim A
      October 18, 2019
      google
      WavyBacon
      September 25, 2019
      google
      Krista Williams
      August 24, 2019

      Quest for Cakes is amazing. I ordered my daughter's first birthday cake and to say they did an amazing job is an understatement. My husband even liked it which says a lot. Will definitely be going there for all of my cakes.

      google
      Melissa Pastore
      August 16, 2019
      google
      Sara Bona
      July 15, 2019
      google
      Mandeep D
      July 9, 2019

      I've ordered kids birthday cakes 2 yrs in a row and the women that work there are just magical. They are able to take your ideas and have an image on the cake. Overall the cake is so fluffy and tasty my kids and I didnt have one complaint. Gluten free, egg free, nut free it's just the right place to get your cakes, cupcakes and cookies from.

      google
      Lindsay Roberts
      July 8, 2019

      The cake is pretty tasty but I do find their prices high. I also sometimes feel when I walk in that I'm a nuisance for being there. I still go in for a big chocolate chip cookie for my kids or the occasional cupcake though :)

      google
      Sabah Ivan
      June 26, 2019

      Great job done! The cake was so good for my daughter's 10th birthday. It was moist and everyone loved it. We just moved to orangeville and am so glad i found this cake shop. I will be going there more often now for all my baking needs. Thank you!

      google
      Meg Twigg
      June 12, 2019

      Dangerously bad for my health. Everything is good and I still haven't tried everything.

      google
      m B
      May 27, 2019

      Love the cookies

      google
      Linda Sawden
      May 18, 2019
      google
      Fawn Lengyel
      May 17, 2019
      google
      Nick m
      April 15, 2019
      google
      Kyle Johnson
      April 14, 2019

      The best cup cakes!